The Fool — Reading Notes

(0 User reviews)   193
In Category - Other Worlds
Mason, David, 1924-1974 Project Gutenberg 2022 Not confirmed
Science fiction; Short stories; Human-alien encounters -- Fiction; Life on other planets -- Fiction; Religion -- Fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 5,293
Reading time 24 min
Text sections 1

The Fool — Reading Notes can be approached with a clearer sense of reading commitment from its source measurements: 5,293 words, 24 min estimated reading time, and 1 detected text section.

The text analysis averages about 19.9 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Science fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

A first-person narrative from a colonial agent on an alien world recounts the story of Duncan, a seemingly incompetent colleague whose kindness toward the warlike Tarchiki baffles and irritates the narrator, raising questions about cultural judgment and the meaning of foolishness.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.4/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

Duncan was a first-rate carpenter!_

[Transcriber's Note: This etext was produced from Infinity Science Fiction, August 1956. Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S. copyright on this publication was renewed.]

Duncan? No, he wasn't the Agent just before you. He was here in 2180--oh, a good thirty years back, Earth-time. The natives say hundreds of years, but they're a short-lived lot. The way they cut each other's throats, it's a wonder any of them live out the life span they've got, anyway.

I came out when Duncan did--knew him pretty well, as well as anybody could. A perfect fool. Knowing him was a real education. Do anything the other way from the way Duncan did it, and you'd be all right.

You wouldn't think it to look at him. Well set-up man, around thirty when he got here, intelligent face, good talker, had a degree--but a fool. Seemed as if he couldn't do anything right. He told me once that he'd been married, and that it had broken up. He more or less implied that his wife had gotten sick of little things--broken dishes, tactless remarks, carelessness. You wouldn't think that would be enough to break up a marriage, but you've got no idea how that sort of thing can add up.

I was clerking for him then. I swear I did all the work. I had to. He couldn't add, couldn't file a record, and couldn't have found one if he'd managed somehow to put it away. I took Agent's inventories, I did most of the trading with the native chiefs, I did everything. Duncan just bumbled around the post, or listened to records, or wrote those silly, hopeless, letters to his ex-wife. He was trying to get her to come back to him. How do I know? Well, who do you think worked the subspace transmitter, as well as doing everything else?

The native thing really annoyed me, though, because it was dangerous. You know the Tarchiki. They look human enough, except for minor details. When it comes to a Tarchik female I'll overlook the green skin and the pointed ears every time. But they aren't entirely like us. They have a liking for war and torture that's really sickening.

Our ancestors? Oh, now, really ... you're talking just like Duncan. That was always his apology for them. He said our own ancestors were pretty bad, too. Certainly they were, but I can't see any ancestor of mine acting the way a Tarchik does with a captured enemy. And they haven't the slightest sense of sportsmanship, either. They'd rather jump you from ambush than fight in the open, and they won't fight at all if the enemy's stronger than they are. That's why they've never made any serious attempt to do in all the Earthmen on their world. That, and greed; they get very good deals from us, and they know it.

Anyway, I'm sure none of my ancestors ever acted like that.

But Duncan was always ready to forgive a Tarchik anything. That used to upset the hell out of them, too, because they expect to be punished when they're caught at anything. They don't understand our reluctance to kill, but they respect a Patrolman's shock gun, and when they get caught stealing or taking each other's tails they know they're going to get a few months in quod, or what they hate much worse, a public flogging. If they didn't get punished, they'd assume it was weakness on our part. Just like kids.

Anyway, there was Duncan, holding long confabs with the Tarchiki, trying to teach them some sort of elementary ethics. Naturally, it didn't take at all. They listened, because they love long speeches, but they never acted on what he said.

He used to tell them that if they stopped chopping each other up and hanging up the rows of tails as war trophies, their lives would be a lot pleasanter. They used to nod and applaud, but Duncan never caught on to the simple fact that they thought this was meant to be a joke. _They_ didn't think their lives weren't pleasant enough. After all, look at their situation. They've got plenty to eat, without working hard for it, plenty of time on their hands--why shouldn't they keep down their surplus population? They don't know any other way, except breaking up their eggs, and they only do that to enemy tribes.

The story opens with a blunt judgment: Duncan was "a perfect fool." The speaker, a former clerk on an alien world, recounts his time working with Duncan, an Earth agent who arrived in 2180. The narrator's voice is sardonic and self-assured, contrasting his own competence with Duncan's bumbling—he couldn't add, file records, or manage trade. Yet the excerpts reveal a deeper tension: Duncan's "foolishness" includes writing letters to his ex-wife and forgiving the Tarchiki, a species the narrator despises for their love of war and torture. The catalog subjects list "Human-alien encounters" and "Religion," but the excerpts show religion only implicitly, through Duncan's unsettling forgiveness.

The Unreliable Narrator's Voice

The narrator presents himself as a reliable witness: "I came out when Duncan did—knew him pretty well." But his account is laced with self-aggrandizement. He claims he "did all the work"—taking inventories, trading with chiefs, even operating the subspace transmitter. His contempt for Duncan is visceral: "Do anything the other way from the way Duncan did it, and you'd be all right." Yet the narrator's own biases emerge. He describes the Tarchiki as having "a liking for war and torture that's really sickening," and dismisses Duncan's comparison to human ancestors as absurd: "I can't see any ancestor of mine acting the way a Tarchik does." The reader is left to weigh the narrator's credibility against his evident prejudice.

Duncan's Foolishness as a Mirror

Duncan's incompetence is cataloged in detail: broken dishes, tactless remarks, inability to file records. But the narrator also reveals that Duncan was "always ready to forgive a Tarchik anything," a trait that "used to upset the hell out of them." This forgiveness, framed as foolishness, unsettles both the aliens and the narrator. The Tarchiki expect punishment; Duncan offers none. The narrator cannot reconcile this behavior with his own worldview, where strength and cunning are virtues. The story thus uses Duncan's apparent folly to question what real wisdom might look like in a colonial context—though the excerpts do not resolve this tension.

Colonial Dynamics and Alien Portrayal

The narrator's description of the Tarchiki is steeped in colonial tropes: they are "short-lived," warlike, cowardly, and greedy. He notes they "get very good deals from us" and have never attacked Earthmen en masse. This economic dependency frames the human-alien encounter as a power imbalance. Duncan's approach—forgiveness without expectation—subverts the colonial logic of punishment and control. The catalog subject "Religion" may point to Duncan's quasi-religious forbearance, but the excerpts offer no explicit doctrine. Instead, the story presents a clash of value systems, with the narrator's pragmatic ruthlessness pitted against Duncan's inexplicable mercy.

The excerpts end before the story's resolution, leaving Duncan's fate and the narrator's final judgment unknown. Readers should attend to the gaps between what the narrator says and what he inadvertently reveals. The story's brevity—around 5,300 words—invites a single-sitting reading, but its layered narration rewards attention to voice and implication. Consider how the title "The Fool" might apply to more than one character.

I finished The Fool — Reading Notes the other evening, and it lingered oddly—that quiet ache of watching someone misunderstood. It reminded me of a certain warmth I once found in The Vibration Wasps — Reading Companion, where gentleness too kept getting mistaken for failure. Strange, how both books sit with me like old, familiar regrets.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

Before you leave, reflect on the book

Use these questions to collect your thoughts before moving on.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Have you finished this book?

2

Did this book hold your interest?

3

Would you pass this book on to a friend?

4

Did the language feel accessible?

Related eBooks